A congregation member and I were chatting about learning a new language as an adult. He said there’s a proverb in Japan to the effect that what you haven’t learned by forty, you’re not going to learn.
Interestingly, I had been reflecting on what I’ve been doing over the past several years, going back a ways before forty: deliberately taking on the challenge of things that scare me. I didn’t take them on for the sake of the challenge itself, but in pursuit of some other goal, but along the way I had to, in Eleanor Roosevelt’s words, do the thing I thought I could not do. They have built on each other, the knowledge of having done one giving me courage to do the next.
Ending an unhappy marriage (age 35). Necessary and excruciating, like doing an amputation on myself. Like walking through fire because going into and through the pain was the only way to get beyond it. When, three years later, my doula asked me to prepare for childbirth by thinking of a time I found the resources to do something I didn’t think I could do, this is what I thought of.
Giving birth (age 38). Longed-for but also very frightening. I’m still awed that I did it. I love this poem about that amazing power, that another church member shared to start a Committee on Ministry meeting, making me want to shout “Yes!”

first steps, Alexis O’Toole (Creative Commons license)
Speaking Spanish to native speakers (age 41). Learning Spanish in class, which I began to do at about age 40, was not particularly difficult and not at all scary. What I wondered was whether I’d have the courage to try out my novice Spanish when we then lived in Mexico for six months. I knew I’d learn more Spanish, and enjoy myself more, if I dared to speak to people—dared, in short, publicly to do something I wasn’t very good at. To my surprise, I dove right in with few qualms. Was I getting braver? It appeared so.
Drawing (age 41). A fear of drawing had paralyzed me for 25 years. Whatever freedom I apparently felt as a young child, when I said I was going to be an artist, had been shriveled by fear by the time of my first semester of college, when I took a drawing class and procrastinated on every assignment. I was terrified. When I planned my “sabbatical of art” for 2010, I intended mostly to make abstract collages, but I assigned myself one drawing class with the aim of putting some of this fear behind me. Not only did the fear fall away, but I fell in love with drawing. For the first time in my memory, I loved to draw. It is still a little intimidating to face the subject and the blank paper, to feel my inadequacy to convey what I see with a piece of charcoal, but I have been drawing every week ever since, and I always look forward to it.
Writing and preaching (age approximately 40, and ongoing). As drawing became a source of joy instead of dread, I asked myself whether I could shift writing in the same way. I had already been getting bolder in my writing and preaching, and then the revelations of my sabbatical accelerated the process. That’s the subject for a longer post focused just on preaching. For now I’ll just say: I could already write, but my sermon writing has taken on a whole new dimension in recent years for reasons that can be summarized as more guts.
And now, at age 44, I am doing something else: Learning to be a supervisor. I became head of staff—UUCPA’s first in I don’t know how long—when I got back from sabbatical in fall 2010, but I and the church still have a lot to learn. That’s scary to admit, even though I preached about the merits of “beginner’s mind” in my very first sermon as UUCPA’s minister. I really like the model that Susan Beaumont is teaching in the seminar I’m in right now, and it both fits UUCPA well, and draws on and develops gifts that I have. I’m looking forward to bringing it back and, over the next few years, adding performance management to the list of things I once didn’t know how to do, and was afraid I couldn’t do, until I began doing them and loving them.
Sometimes we do learn new things at forty.
6 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 7, 2013 at 6:31 am
David Zucker
my daughter amy continues to amaze me. Maybe I got it from you. Who’s learning Greek at age mumbledymumble? And Mom is no slouch in the never-too-late-to-learn department either. Love, Amy
LikeLike
March 7, 2013 at 3:03 pm
Laurel McClure
I believe that many of us gain courage along with our years. Some of the our fears fade with more experience of life. This can make it easier to try new things.
Often, it is because circumstances force us to attempt what we might have shied away from, given the choice. If you want to be a parent, and go about having kids in the usual way, you will be some point find yourself giving birth. If you have birth attendants who support you in your labor, giving birth can be a tremendous experience of the power of your own body. I love the poem!
Work also places demands on us that stretch our capabilities beyond what we might have imagined ourselves capable of. When I decided to apply to medical school, I set myself on a course that would require me to develop one unfamiliar skill after another, and would commit me to never- ending study of many aspects of human health and disease, learning new things and relearning what I thought I knew, every day.
Sometimes a new pursuit challenges our sense of ourselves. Yoga for me, as for many, has stretched my sense of what is humanly possible along with my limbs. Started in my 40’s, in hope of helping heal a knee injury.
Kids are an inspiration. I had my son at 35, and my daughter at 41; when I saw them trying new things every single day, standing and taking a step and falling and getting up to try again, how could I do less?
Thanks for these many moving examples, Laurel. Parenting is certainly a huge challenge we learn as we go, though I didn’t enter it with fear and trembling (not enough, anyway!). Maybe it is true that watching the munchkin fearlessly face the unknown has given me courage. –AZM
LikeLike
April 3, 2013 at 9:41 pm
Laurel McClure
On the other hand! Parenting did give me a whole new set of fears. It created this tremendous new area of vulnerability, the fear that something could harm my child. And of course our children WILL suffer, since pain and suffering and grievous harm come to all of us, in the natural course of
life–we all die, inevitably, and there will be many a rough patch before then.
But the irrational nature of some of the fears! I would lie in bed, thinking about him in his crib in the next room, envisioning what I would do when the furnace under the floor grate outside his door exploded into a wall of flame–I LEAP into action, out the back door, around the side of the house, break the window to get to him–!! I had envisioned the whole dramatic rescue in detail.
Parenting requires a special sort of courage, to go with the new fears: to watch someone you love dearly, maybe more than your own dear self, suffer and struggle; and to let them struggle, let them grapple with the pain and difficulty of life, in order to become fully human. We can and should offer comfort, when it is wanted and needed; but we cannot and should not try to make the road smooth and easy.
LikeLike
March 7, 2013 at 11:01 pm
Beth Nord
Amy: I really admire your abilities in your role at UUCPA as well as your ability to stand up (almost) every Sunday and give us fresh insights into all kinds of topics. I also admire your thoughtful self-examination and I thank you for sharing all this with us. Thank you, Beth! –AZM
LikeLike
April 12, 2013 at 6:42 am
WesLive: Wesleyan's Community Blog » Blog Archive » Morgenstern ’90: sometimes we do learn new things at forty
[…] Read more here… […]
LikeLike
May 28, 2015 at 7:34 am
A writing evolution (3) | Sermons in Stones
[…] True vulnerability invites vulnerability from others. That takes courage. I’ve gotten braver by doing things that scare me. […]
LikeLike